
The Godfrey Hotel Boston
Best for downtown sightseeing, quick access to Boston Common and the Freedom Trail.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Godfrey Hotel Boston is a four-star, downtown Boston hotel in restored early-1900s buildings, aimed at travelers who want immediate access to Boston Common, the Freedom Trail and the Theatre District. Hotel Commonwealth is a well-known 4.5-star hotel in Kenmore–Fenway, best for guests attending games, concerts or visiting Boston University and the Commonwealth Avenue corridor.
Updated · about 2.8 km apart

Best for downtown sightseeing, quick access to Boston Common and the Freedom Trail.

Best for Fenway Park events, Kenmore Square nightlife, and guests tied to Boston University or the Longwood area.
When The Godfrey Hotel Boston wins: Choose The Godfrey if you want to be in the heart of Downtown Crossing, a short walk to Boston Common, the Freedom Trail and downtown theatres, plus easy access to a Nikkei-Peruvian restaurant (RUKA) and a 24-hour fitness center.
When Hotel Commonwealth wins: Pick Hotel Commonwealth if proximity to Fenway Park, Kenmore Square and Boston University matters — it also offers a larger meeting/ballroom footprint and on-site Japanese restaurant Blue Ribbon Sushi noted in the supplier listing.
Bottom line: Both are upscale, location-driven Boston hotels serving different itineraries — The Godfrey is better for historic downtown sightseeing and theatre access; Hotel Commonwealth is better for Fenway events and the Kenmore/Boston University neighborhood.
| Category | The Godfrey Hotel Boston | Hotel Commonwealth |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Restored early-1900s downtown property with contemporary food/drink venues and adult-focused check-in rules. | Upscale, neighborhood hotel closely associated with Fenway–Kenmore, sports and university traffic. |
| Location | Downtown Crossing — 1–3 minute walk to Boston Common and the Freedom Trail. | Fenway–Kenmore — steps from Commonwealth Avenue Mall, Kenmore Square and 0.4 mi (0.6 km) from Fenway Park. |
| Size | Smaller, occupies two historic buildings; 7 room types listed. | Larger: supplier listing notes 245 guestrooms and many room type names. |
| Check-in / age policy | Standard check-in 3:00 PM; guests must be 21+ to check in (lead guest). | Check-in begins 4:00 PM; minimum check-in age 18 (supplier listing). |
| Pools | No on-site pool or hot tub. | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | RUKA Restobar (Peruvian-Japanese), George Howell Coffee, Lobby Bar; RUKA ToGo room service evenings. | Two on-site restaurants including Blue Ribbon Sushi and a bar/lounge; cooked-to-order breakfast available for a fee. |
| Spa & wellness | No dedicated named spa; in-room massages available and a 24-hour fitness center. | 24-hour health club and fitness facilities listed; no dedicated named spa confirmed. |
| Known for | Downtown location, theatre access, RUKA Restobar and George Howell Coffee. | Fenway Park proximity, Commonwealth Avenue address, sizable conference/ballroom space. |
| Parking & fees | Valet parking only (surcharge); resort/other fees reported separately by booking channels. | Valet parking available (surcharge); breakfast and valet fees may apply. |
| Accessibility & meeting space | Accessible rooms and one 500 sq ft Blake Meeting Room (boardroom up to ~18–40 depending on layout). | Wheelchair accessible options; large conference/meeting space (~16,446 sq ft). |
The Godfrey sits in Downtown Crossing, steps from Boston Common, theatres and the Freedom Trail.
Choose The Godfrey for short walking trips to Boston’s historic and theatre districts.
Hotel Commonwealth is positioned on Commonwealth Avenue in the Fenway–Kenmore neighborhood, with strong ties to Fenway Park and Boston University.
Pick Hotel Commonwealth when your plans revolve around Fenway, Kenmore Square or nearby universities.
The Godfrey lists seven room types across two restored buildings, mixing standard and studio/corner loft options.
Rooms at The Godfrey focus on downtown convenience and a boutique historic feel.
Hotel Commonwealth lists many room and suite names (245 guestrooms noted), from standard rooms to themed suites and executive options.
Hotel Commonwealth gives a wider range of room types and more suite options for varied needs.
Dining at The Godfrey centers on RUKA Restobar (Peruvian-Japanese), George Howell Coffee and an intimate Lobby Bar.
The Godfrey doubles as a downtown dining destination for Nikkei-style cuisine and specialty coffee.
Hotel Commonwealth offers two restaurants including Blue Ribbon Sushi and a bar/lounge, plus room service and cooked-to-order breakfast for a fee.
Hotel Commonwealth is convenient for pre- and post-game dining with multiple on-site food & drink outlets.
The Godfrey does not have a pool; its key amenities include a 24-hour fitness center and boutique meeting space.
Expect a strong fitness offering and small, flexible meeting space rather than resort-style amenities.
Hotel Commonwealth lists a 24-hour health club and substantial conference/ballroom space rather than resort-style pools.
Hotel Commonwealth emphasizes event and meeting capacity along with fitness access rather than pool facilities.
The Godfrey supports late-night cocktails and downtown nightlife with its Lobby Bar and nearby theatres.
The Godfrey fits travelers who plan evening theatre or downtown dining and late cocktails.
Hotel Commonwealth’s nightlife value is driven by Kenmore Square, Fenway post-game crowds and on-site dining.
Hotel Commonwealth is convenient for event nights, game days and Kenmore’s evening scene.

The Godfrey is a short walk to Boston Common and the Freedom Trail start, ideal for historic downtown sightseeing.

Hotel Commonwealth is the logical choice for Fenway events, Kenmore Square conveniences and Boston University proximity.

Hotel Commonwealth offers substantially more conference and ballroom space for larger corporate or social events.

The Godfrey combines RUKA Restobar and George Howell Coffee for distinct dining and specialty-coffee options right in Downtown Crossing.
The Godfrey Hotel Boston is much closer — about a 2–3 minute walk to Boston Common.
Hotel Commonwealth — it’s roughly 0.4 miles (0.6 km) from Fenway Park and is positioned for game-day access.
No — both properties offer breakfast for an additional fee (Hotel Commonwealth lists cooked-to-order breakfast for a surcharge; The Godfrey offers continental breakfast for a surcharge).
The Godfrey has no on-site pool; Hotel Commonwealth pool details are not published in the supplier listing.
Explore how The Godfrey Hotel Boston stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·